“We Thought We Did Everything Right…”
That’s what one nonprofit leader told me after their $75,000 grant application was rejected.
They had a compelling mission.
The community impact was real. And yet—they didn’t get the funding. Sound familiar?
Here’s the truth: most nonprofits don’t lose grants because their cause isn’t worthy. They lose because of one fixable mistake.
In this post, I’ll break down the #1 mistake that keeps nonprofits from getting funded, explain why it happens, and give you clear, actionable steps to fix it.
Whether you’re a beginner or seasoned grant writer, this guide will help you shift how you approach every proposal going forward.
Pro Tip: Bookmark this post. Share it with your team. And start winning more grants.
The #1 Mistake: Writing the Proposal Without a Funders-First Strategy
Let me say it plainly:
Too many nonprofits write proposals from their perspective instead of the funder’s.
This one misstep sabotages even the most passionate applications.
Here’s what it looks like:
- Talking too much about your history but not enough about the measurable impact.
- Using insider language that funders don’t relate to.
- Skipping alignment with the funder’s specific goals.
It’s not that the proposal is bad—it’s that it’s not strategic. Funders want to solve their priorities with the help of your work. Not the other way around.
What Funders Really Want (But Most Nonprofits Miss)
Before you even open a grant application, you should be thinking:
“What is this funder trying to solve—and how does our work help them do it?”
Here’s what most funders care about:
- Clear community impact: What will change as a result of this project?
- Data-driven need: Can you prove this program is addressing a real gap?
- Sustainability: Will your work outlast their funding?
- Alignment with mission: Does your project clearly support their stated goals?
When you skip this mindset shift, your proposal becomes “just another ask.”
Real Story: How One Youth Nonprofit Got Rejected—Then Reframed
A faith-based youth mentoring nonprofit applied for a $50,000 grant to expand their weekend program.
The funder’s focus?
Reducing gun violence in urban communities.
They wrote a beautiful proposal—but it was all about mentorship, not public safety.
Result? Rejected.
Once we reframed the project as preventing youth from entering the juvenile system through consistent mentorship, tied to local crime data, they got funded.
Same program.
Different frame.
Strategic win.
How to Fix This Mistake (and Reframe Every Proposal)
Step 1: Read the Funder’s Website Like It’s a Map
Don’t skim.
Study:
- What language do they use to describe problems they fund?
- Do they talk about equity, prevention, innovation, collaboration? Use it.
- Look at who they’ve funded before. What kind of orgs and projects made the cut?
Pro Tip: Highlight key funder phrases and mirror them in your proposal—without copying and pasting.
Step 2: Turn Your Program Into a Problem-Solving Tool
Ask yourself:
- What urgent problem are we solving?
- Who is affected and how?
- What measurable change will happen because of this funding?
Use these to anchor your Needs Statement and Goals sections.
Step 3: Show You’re a Partner—Not Just a Recipient
Funders want grantees who share their values and vision.
So show them:
- How your organization fits their mission
- Your track record of success (brief, but powerful)
- Your plan for sustainability and community impact
Use language like:
- “Our program directly supports the funder’s priority of…”
- “This proposal aligns with your mission to…”
Bonus: 5 Quick Wins to Make Your Proposal Funder-First
Stop using “we need” language and use “community impact” language instead.
Start your proposal with the funder’s mission in mind, not your own.
Use real data, not general statements.
Include a logic model or outcome chart if allowed.
Use active, clear verbs. (Avoid: “We hope to.” Use: “We will.”)
“You’re not just asking for money—you’re offering a solution to the funder’s priority problem.”
Want Help Fixing This in Your Next Proposal?
If this sounds like a shift you need to make, you don’t have to do it alone.
Join our $1,999/year Founding Membership to get:
- 12-month training curriculum
- Done-for-you proposal templates
- Monthly grant reviews and funder analysis
- Live coaching with experienced grant writers
- Plus, access to our private strategy circle
Become a Founding Member Today
Or
Join our Free Weekly Newsletter
Let’s turn your mission into funded impact.
Quick FAQ
Q1: Isn’t it okay to share our story in the proposal?
Yes, but your story should serve the funder’s goals. Frame your narrative in terms of the impact they care about.
Q2: What if our program doesn’t perfectly align with their focus?
Don’t force it. It’s better to wait for the right fit than stretch and get rejected.
Q3: Can we just hire a grant writer to fix this?
Sure—but even great writers need your insights. Strategic framing is a team effort.
Final Takeaway
The #1 mistake nonprofits make is writing from their own point of view—not the funder’s.
Fixing this changes everything. It helps you stand out, show alignment, and earn trust.
Start today.
Reread that open grant.
Ask yourself: What is this funder really looking for?
Then frame your proposal to meet that need.
Explore Templates & Strategies
Join the Membership
Let’s get you funded.
